Alachua sued twice by developer
Hello from Gainesville, Florida. It's Monday, October 19, and you're listening to StreetSmart. I'm Seth Johnson. StreetSmart is a weekly podcast from Mainstreet Daily News, where we cover local news that informs, engages, and inspires listeners like you. Here's the top headlines we're following.
Seth:Downtown Gainesville stakeholders are pushing Alachua County to open the under construction courthouse parking garage for public use. Business representatives said the area needs more parking for nights and weekends. The county commission said they'll discuss the parking garage at an upcoming meeting. The Rock School and Gainesville Christian Community School are developing STEM programs that could help students communicate with satellites and astronauts in space. The projects were presented at the Radio Amateur Satellite Corporation Conference in Jacksonville.
Seth:The city of Newberry directed its staff to draft a notice of intent for a plan that could create a road assessment levied against residents. The commission voted three to two to move forward in case amendment three passes, but the mayor said there's no appetite for a new assessment at the moment.
Seth:UF's nursing program rose to be the number 12 program in the nation according to US News and World Report rankings. From last year, the program jumped 28 spots and is now ahead of more than 600 other programs.
Seth:The city of Chiefland received $3,500,000 from the rural infrastructure fund. According to the governor's office, the funding will support a 55,000 square foot grocery store and related infrastructure.
Seth:UF Health's mobile stroke unit passed 3,000 calls as it reached three years in service this month. Stroke patients treated by the unit averaged two fewer days in the hospital, and the overall stroke mortality rate is forty five percent lower with the unit. To learn more about any of these stories, visit mainstreetdailynews.com. Every day, we're adding new information to keep you informed, and it's all free with no paywall, thanks to our generous members.
Seth:Welcome to another episode of the StreetSmart podcast. I'm Seth Johnson, and I'm with co host Lillian Hamman this week, and we tried to pull a fast one on our listeners last week.
Lillian:Yeah, Seth. Do you think we got them?
Seth:No, I don't think we got them. Even though we said it was the Gators bye week for football, the Gators did play on Saturday. Now whether or not people wanted them to have played that game once it was over against South Carolina is up for debate, but it did happen, and we're sorry we said it was a bye week. But there were a lot of events last weekend and a lot of events coming up this weekend, which actually is the Gators bye week, which I think is coming just in time.
Lillian:Yeah. You'll wanna stay tuned for the latter part of this podcast. We'll go through some of those events you can go to. But for now, we're gonna jump into our feature story.
Seth:Yeah. Lillian, lead the way on this. This is something you've been covering for a little while in the city of Alachua, and it's a development that's been kind of in the planning stages for years, and now the developer has said, enough. The city of Alachua is moving the goalposts. It's kind of putting burdens on them, and they've sued with...
Seth:Is it three different lawsuits by this developer against the city of Alachua?
Lillian:Three have come up in the city commission meetings, but only two so far filed in the clerk of court. We did a story earlier this month on one that could go up to $10,000,000 against the city, and technically against the planning director as well. The developer said that was for delays in setting a hearing for moving the infrastructure plans forward for a storm water treatment facility.
Seth:Yeah. And that lawsuit gets pretty in the weeds with some of the technicalities of municipal planning and stages and, especially for really large developments like this. But essentially, they said the city wasn't playing fair and by state statute when it came to this development, we're putting extra stringent requirements on them as it came to tests and environmental tests with the carciography.
Lillian:Again, just to kinda zoom out, this Terra project has five different pieces and the Terra April piece kinda holds the key to the rest of them. It's supposed to have the storm water infrastructure for, you know, and up to a thousand homes and commercial components on these other developments. And the... One of the largest concerns is that it is around Mill Creek Sink, which feeds into the Florida aquifer and, you know, concerns from multiple different agencies including the county. They set aside $1,000,000 for litigation fees potentially to use against this kind of development.
Lillian:So there's there's been issues before, but I mean, these are these are no small lawsuits. This one was over 280 pages and the next one we'll talk about was almost 200 pages. So lots of different records and things kind of laying out their argument.
Seth:I mean, it's just a lot of bedtime reading for you, Lillian, to help put you right to sleep.
Lillian:Yes. It's... I... All I dream about is Alachua and lawsuits.
Seth:But it's interesting because that county involvement that you mentioned, they set aside a million dollars saying, you know, if we need to step in for litigation because we're worried about environmental issues, we'll have that money. And that's something I covered several years ago. And I think the initial stages of this terror development were covered by our previous Alachua reporter, Glory Wrights, and now you're in there.
Lillian:The biggest vote recently was in January. The Planning and Zoning Board denied a special exception permit for that storm water infrastructure on Terra April, and that's what the city is using to say that there's now a one year holding period where because that was denied, the developer has to wait another year before they can apply. The board also requested that the applicant do geologic testing with the city's experts on all parcels in the Terra project, not just two that were in question. And the lawsuit says that that is not fair. They should just be able to test the parcels in question and not have to do other stuff.
Lillian:But they've already paid, you know, more than $70,000 for the testing. So they were kind of, you know, expecting, hey, we've done the testing. We should be able to move forward with a hearing. But that's not what's happening.
Seth:And that $10,000,000 that you mentioned, that's for monetary damages from delays and the potential value of the site, and that's for the first lawsuit. But with the second lawsuit, what did that one entail?
Lillian:Yeah. This one actually came earlier in September, and that was accusing the city of overcharging, delaying, and redacting public records related to the Terra applications without justifying any of it. One of the bills the developer received was almost $90,000 for public records related to their own Terra applications. The argument claims that a lot of the documents requested were readily available. They weren't anything that needed redactions.
Lillian:And even if they did, according to the developer, the city has not provided why it's redacted all those pages. I mean, one of the documents was a 317 page file for Terra Phoenicia, is one of the components of the Terra developments, and all of it was blank. So just things like that. They, you know, had duplicate files in these thousands of pages of records. They had, you know, just image files, like just things that weren't...
Lillian:Things that didn't necessarily need to be pulled. But... Yeah. And then just taking months to get them back. And there was also some discrepancy with...
Lillian:For attorney fees and the fees paid to the city's external experts. So the developer was requesting all the invoices for those things and they just weren't getting them.
Seth:And working in the news, you know, we're no strangers to public records requests. And once you start talking about records where a city or an entity has to redact, that means it has to go through their attorneys, which means the attorneys fees could then be paid, you know, could could be pushed to whoever's requesting those documents. They can rack up quickly, $90,000 for files and then saying those files were incomplete or had some, things shifted around that large bill.
Lillian:Yeah. And this isn't the first time issues with public records in Alachua have come up. I did a story a little bit ago about a Alachua City company Christmas party video that had been going around. People heard that there was questionable content in it. Anyways, people were trying to request it and it was coming back redacted.
Lillian:Somebody threatened to sue and then finally, the video got released unredacted. So just issues like that. There have been issues with public records and terror before, but I did reach out to the city and, got a response from the city manager. He said they're aware of the suits. They just can't comment right now because it is active litigation.
Lillian:But he said that the city is still committed to transparency and accountability and fair and consistent administration of city processes.
Seth:Yeah. And obviously, the city has not filed their response to these lawsuits. And sometimes in these lawsuit cases, it's hard, especially as a non attorney, you know, you read one side and you're like, wow, this seems like a slam dunk. And then you read the other person's response and you're like, oh, wow, maybe not so much. Something that takes a little while before it kind of fully fleshes out but it's on the books.
Seth:It's something City of Alachua is gonna have to be dealing with, and it's gonna perhaps put these terror developments and what actually happens there in the long term on pause for even longer for residents who have been very vocal about this development.
Lillian:Alright. Let's jump straight into our news forecast and then the event segments. The High Springs City Commission will hold a special meeting Thursday to review applications for an interim city manager. Also on Thursday, the city of Gainesville will have a general policy committee meeting and then the city plan board will convene that evening.
Seth:Now for our event segment with plenty of family friendly events this weekend. The AVP Grass Nationals are coming to High Springs. The three day grass volleyball tournament features competitive doubles and triples and coed team play with music, a water slide, food vendors, and merch, and spectators can attend for free. The Florida Bat Festival will land in Gainesville on Saturday at the Luby Bat Conservancy. Starting at 10AM, the annual event features live bat encounters, wildlife exhibits, educational activities, local vendors, food, and a beer garden for guests.
Seth:The Sweetwater Branch Inn is hosting a traditional English high tea at 2PM on Sunday. For $40, guests can enjoy savory bites and sweet treats, all in an elegant atmosphere. The five day Friends of the Library book sale kicks off at 9AM on Saturday with more than 500,000 items for sale at discounted prices. Shoppers can find books, comics, parts, CDs, DVDs, vinyls, and more. Tuesday, we'll offer half price items followed by 10¢ day on Wednesday.
Seth:Now, Lillian, we have both been to the bat houses at UF, but we've not been able to get out to the Florida Bat Festival, but we were close last week.
Lillian:So close. We attended trivia at Blackadder Brewing Company here in Gainesville, and that was the prize at stake. Two tickets to the Lubee Bat Conservancy Fall Bat Festival.
Seth:Unfortunately, our team were not the winners of that trivia night, but we'll see if we can still go out there and see some bats this weekend.
Lillian:I sure pulled my weight.
Seth:Yeah. Lillian got a good number of questions, and I'm just gonna have to do more reps with the trivia. And that's all we've got for this week's StreetSmart brought to you by Mainstreet Daily News and made possible by our generous members. You can access more free local news at mainstreetdailynews.com. We'll be back next week with more stories that matter to you because they take place right here in Alachua County.
Seth:Take a minute to share StreetSmart and help us continue the work. Our theme music is Sunset Sonata by Gainesville's Ska band, Now Leaving Space. This episode is a production of MARC Media.