Bonus—Transparency, taking office with Nathan Crabbe
Welcome to StreetSmart. It's Monday, November 9. I'm Lillian Hamman. Over the next two episodes, cohost Seth Johnson will bring you two interviews with candidates who won office in August. Nathan Crabbe earned a seat to the Gainesville City Commission while Tina Certain won a spot on the Alachua County Board of County Commissioners, moving from her current school board seat.
Lillian:We'll return with our typical episode lineup on November 23.
Seth:Nathan Crabbe, welcome to the StreetSmart podcast studio here in Gainesville. Thanks for having me. Absolutely. I think you are the first, city commissioner or soon to be city commissioner to make it on the podcast.
Nathan Crabbe:Great. I'm happy to be here. Breaking the ground. Listened to podcasts, so I'm I'm glad to be part
Seth:Glad to have you here. And it's interesting for me since you have a career as a journalist and then me covering the city of Gainesville as a journalist. I mean, how has that shaped how you campaigned and then how you're looking forward to this job as a commissioner?
Nathan Crabbe:Well, you know, the... I was lucky enough to, in my last years with the Gainesville Sun, be the opinion editor, which meant I, you know, I wrote about a lot of lot of different issues affecting our community. So I know a little bit about all the major issues. So when I came into running for office, I felt like I was able to go knocking on people's doors and talk about virtually anything. But I think that my my realization since being elected is it's a lot different covering issues than actually being part of the decision making process.
Nathan Crabbe:You know, I've been attending a lot of meetings, both city commission meetings and some of the other meetings like the plan board and the Parks and Rec board and and and things like that, trying to learn how things work. And and you realize that, you know, you cover those meetings as a journalist and kinda know a little bit about everything. But when you start getting in the weeds of of of how the sausage is made, it's a whole different experience.
Seth:A little more weighty too, knowing that you don't have to just cover the vote and say what people voted, but you had to actually cast one yourself.
Nathan Crabbe:Exactly. Exactly. And, you know, you bring all those kind of, you know, the the things that I used to get bugged about when I was covering meetings is when commissioners, didn't do their homework, when they would ask questions that I was like, it's in the backup material. So I've... I I, hope to be, a person who is well versed on all the issues, before I even get to the dais of doing my research beforehand and using kind of the tools of journalism and applying them to, understanding government.
Seth:And probably a lot of prep work in these next four months. You kind of have a long lead way between winning the election and then actually stepping into the seat. I know there's a lot of Sunshine meetings happening this week. And what are you learning from commissioners, and what are you learning from attending these meetings? Yeah.
Nathan Crabbe:I I feel very fortunate that my election was decided in August that I didn't have to keep running, because I've been able to have those kinds of meetings. And, yes, I've been in meeting with individual commissioners. And and, one of the first things I learned is that Sunshine Law applies to me even though I'm not officially a commissioner yet, so we have to notice these meetings. So I've been meeting with individual commissioners. Just had one recently.
Nathan Crabbe:And, and what I'm learning is I'm I'm I'm joining a great commission. They've done a lot of work on issues like affordable housing, more investment in the East Side, you know, these sorts of things, improving traffic safety and and and the sorts of things that I've long cared about and written about. And I'm glad to see that I'm gonna be, joining a commission that's done a lot of great work on that that I'd to help build on.
Seth:And then coming from your background as a journalist and also saw it on your campaign website, you talked about transparency in city government. How do you think Gainesville has done historically when you're covering them, and how are they doing right now with that? Gosh. Let me think. How
Nathan Crabbe:has Gainesville done historically? You know, I think that the... That's ebbed and flowed in terms of, transparency. I think we're in a good place right now, and I'd like to be as transparent as humanly possible. You know, there are things like, some commissioners...
Nathan Crabbe:All the commissioners used to have their emails up online. Now it's only down to a couple. I'd like to continue in the, follow the practice of the current commissioner in in the District 2 seat, Ed Boak, who has his commissioner... Who has his emails online. I'd like to put mine online.
Nathan Crabbe:And, you know, I'd like to also use, you know, the the tools of, social media to really communicate with the public about what's going on. I mean, I wanna hear from people about these issues that the commission is deciding on. People will oftentimes say, oh, I, you know, I I didn't know this was happening. And, you know, part of that is that they need to read, publications like Mainstreet and and and the other, journalism in town. But, I think commissioners also have a duty, a responsibility really to communicate with their constituents about what they're gonna be voting on and getting their input.
Seth:And another kind of transparency one, kind of insight based upon yet, it really impacts people's legal notices and how that's changed in Florida as well. What are your thoughts on that and kind of the trends back and forth?
Nathan Crabbe:Gosh. I mean, you know, I think that a lot of those... The legal notices, much like classified ads and, a lot of the other things used to be the lifeblood of newspapers and really the way that they, they were able to sustain themselves. And I I I know that a lot of that has changed, and some of that stuff's been put online. You know, I I I certainly mourn, the decline of journalism, quite frankly, that that, that in terms of the the staffing of an institution like the Gainesville Sun, there used to be a bustling newsroom when I first started in in 2005, and and there...
Nathan Crabbe:And there's a lot fewer people to cover the community since then. Now I'm glad to see that there are online publications like like this one, kinda helping to fill that gap, and I hope that there's there's there's more of that. I think that the more journalism, the better. The more eyes in the community looking at the things that our local government is doing. I think it keeps local government accountable and honest.
Seth:Do you think legal notices serve the same... Have the same impact when they're on a government website versus in any kind of public newspaper?
Nathan Crabbe:You know, I'd I'd like to see... You know, I I think in an ideal world, we would have those in in in the news publications. In an ideal world, people would be reading the news every day. Right? I mean, you know, I grew up...
Nathan Crabbe:You know, I'm old enough that I grew up having the habit of reading the newspaper every day. Saw my parents doing it over a cup of coffee in the morning, and that's that's the way that I started every day. I I still start every day. Now I'm not reading a physical paper anymore. I'm reading it online, so I certainly understand that as technology changes, things like where you would put a legal notice, at change.
Nathan Crabbe:But I really hope people get back in the habit of of of, you know, that that's part of their daily routine is is finding out what's going on in their community through, you know, news publications.
Seth:And then turning to some of the issues that you campaigned on. One of them was kind of the city government, and you said they must respond better to needs of residents. I kind of had two questions off of that. Kind of what needs and then what changes to make that happen?
Nathan Crabbe:Gosh. Responding the needs of residents. I mean, you know, I think that... And, you know, I... All this was new to me.
Nathan Crabbe:Right? I I was, a journalist and never in politics and and hadn't really thought, too hard about running until until this this race came up and and and recognized that maybe I had something to offer. And, and this was a way of getting off the sidelines and and making a greater contribution. But part of parts of running for office are no fun or at least I didn't find the fun. Like, raising money, I think, was not my favorite thing.
Nathan Crabbe:But knocking doors was, I think, that, it really gave me a good idea of what the folks in my district were talking and caring about. And I knocked over on on more than 3,000 doors. And, you know, what I found is affordability is more than a buzzword. It's it's it's really people's lives are being affected by high prices and things like energy and housing. And I think what the the city commission does have a role to play in making sure people can can better afford these things, making sure affordable housing is available to people like workers in our community.
Nathan Crabbe:I think that people, like teachers and nurses and firefighters, should be able to live close to to their employers, and they should be able to have housing options that allow that. And and energy, know that GRU is not within the control of the city commission, but think the city commission should do... Be doing whatever it can to help people better afford their energy bills too. So I think things like that are what I heard a lot of from people in knocking knocking doors. But I also hear...
Nathan Crabbe:Heard a lot of people caring about our natural environment, which is something that's very near and dear to my heart. So I would like to, as a commissioner, make that one of my, if not my top priority and and really make protecting our environment and and making sure that we have a community that's resilient to the challenges of things like climate change. Those are the things that I care about most, and I think that a lot of people in our community do too.
Seth:What does making the environment your top priority look like? What are some of the practical measures you as a commissioner can kind of bring forward on that topic? Well, I think that, the good thing
Nathan Crabbe:is there are things you can do that that check check a few different boxes. Like, let's say, protecting land along creeks as an example. So what does that accomplish? Well, one, you can reduce flooding in the community if you protect land along creeks. Two, you can improve water quality in the community by doing that.
Nathan Crabbe:And three, you can create recreational opportunities for people by having trails and greenways and this sort of thing, which improves people's health in the long run. Right? So I think that I think that the the environmental issues are sometimes framed as, you know, tree huggers and and and that sort of thing when in reality, they're economic issues. Our community is stronger and better economically speaking when we have things like, you know, a robust system of trails and green ways that that, get people out into the woods and and and and help improve their health while also improving our environment.
Seth:We're talking about institutional knowledge before starting. And wasn't there also a plan with the Hogtown Creek Greenway that was kind of in the works where you... Did you cover that at the time? You know, it's... It it preceded me, but
Nathan Crabbe:I I wrote about it a little bit. I mean, I think that we've talked about the Hog Town Greenway in our community since the nineties is an example of something that I I I would like to try to accelerate or get get moving again. I think that I I was very pleased to see mayor Ward in an interview that he did recently talk about goals about land conservation and and and further connecting the Greenway. And I I share those priorities and hope to really make a effort to... You know, I think that, as a reporter, I often got frustrated by the study would always, or the city would would oftentimes study things, and there'd be a report.
Nathan Crabbe:It would sit on a shelf. I I... You know, and I've I've heard it referred to by, commissioner Eastman sometimes as, we sometimes have, paralysis by analysis in our community. And I think that we've we've done the studies and things like the Hogtown Greek... Greenway.
Nathan Crabbe:There's probably a dozen reports sitting on in... On various city shelves, and now it's the time to get stuff like that done.
Seth:Also, with the affordability issue, one thing that city has done recently is inclusionary zoning. It seems like they're kind of at a fork in the road where the Planning Board's talked about and the City Commission's talked about how do we implement that? Is that something we look for cash from developers and then we go and develop affordable housing? Or do we want units on-site that developers kind of have to build and manage there in their complex? Thoughts on that issue as now I know that's coming before the state commission's kind of a policy decision that they're going to make on that affordability issue.
Nathan Crabbe:Sure. And and, you know, I will I will freely admit that I'm I'm still learning a lot about issues like housing. I mean, I went to a plan board meeting the other night in the different zoning distinctions of the community. I'm gonna have to get up to speed on. But I think that a lot of work is...
Nathan Crabbe:Particularly commissioner Eastman has done a lot of work on the housing issue that I... That I'm I'm happy to piggyback on and and and help build on. I think that it's a combination of approaches that the city can do in terms of of of of of zoning and this sort of thing. But also, there are things like investing in actual housing that you have to do, and the city has has has been doing some... A lot of great work in that area.
Nathan Crabbe:I I think the workforce housing side of things is is is a gap that I see, and I'd I'd love for, you know, large employers like the University of Florida to be part of that process because I think UF and and and and places like it are better served when their employees can live live nearby. I think that my quality of life certainly is is is is great because of of the proximity that that that... Of where I live to where my my wife lives... Works five minutes away, and I know that that's great for our family. We have schools and parks within within near distance.
Nathan Crabbe:So I think people should be able to live close to where where they go to school and where they work. And and and particularly for UF, I think we're benefited by getting cars off the road and having more UF employees living living closer to the campus.
Seth:And part of that is infrastructure, RTS. Right? Getting people to their work and using that, gets cars off the road. So you just broke ground on their East Side transfer station. Right.
Seth:How would you rate Gainesville's infrastructure right now and the plans that are kind of in the works? Well, it could be improved. I mean, I I
Nathan Crabbe:think that one... I often heard about people complaining about roads, when I knocked on doors. Regularly, they were talking about roads that the city doesn't control. I think the road in front of Santa Fe was one that came up on multiple occasions. I'm glad to see the county has made that a higher in their priority list because I think it's important to make sure that our infrastructure is is is strong and and resilient.
Nathan Crabbe:So, yeah, I think that we could do... We could always do better, in in in terms of infrastructure. And I think infrastructure goes beyond just, gray infrastructure, meaning concrete, to green infrastructure too. I think that, you know, again, when we talk about protecting our environment, we're we're talking about economic development at some point as well is when we protect wetlands and protect green areas that do things like, reduce the urban heat island effect and reduce flooding. I think it benefits our communities as a whole, improves our quality of life, and allows businesses and everything to be able to thrive.
Seth:And can you talk about the importance of the CRA District and then wild spaces public places making some of these happen? Yeah. And, I
Nathan Crabbe:mean, I think that, you know, the the the city has been, doing a lot of building. You mentioned the East Side Transfer Station, which I think is a great thing. I think it's not only a great thing for transportation. I think that, my understanding is that there's gonna be community spaces there as well, which are are needed. It's also part of a larger, amount of development around GTEC and and and and that area that I think has a lot of potential, and I'm glad to see happening.
Nathan Crabbe:And so we're also doing things like building fire stations and this sort of thing. So I I I think that we've done a lot of great public investments, and we could... But we could always, you know, we could always be doing more. I think that the CRA is is, you know, been transformed in the last few years and is is sunsetting, so we're gonna have to figure out a different approach to some of that things, like in terms of downtown in particular. We wanna make sure that we have a thriving downtown.
Nathan Crabbe:So if it's not gonna be CRA money, how do we achieve that? And that's something that I think that we're gonna have, definitely as a as a priority for the commission to come.
Seth:With, you know, GRU and the kind of management, debate back and forth with the new authority or not, it's kind of impacted city finances, you know, whether or not you are for that or against that and everything that's involved with that debate. We'll leave that to the side for now. Otherwise, we'd need another episode. But how necessary have these specialized funding sources been to keep the city of Gainesville at the level it's at or even to move it forward in the years to come?
Nathan Crabbe:So I think that, you know, there's there's a perception at the very least that that that, GRU had been used as the city's piggy bank in the past. Now we've gone to the opposite extreme where we have the GRU authority kind of deciding what it does, you know, what to do with the transfer, you know, based on things like, oh, we're spending this much on lawyers. We'll drop the transfer by that much and making these decisions that I don't think are certainly not in the city's best interest. I think that GRU should contribute to our community much like any utility contributes to the community they're in. For investor owned utilities, for example, they have something called franchise fees.
Nathan Crabbe:And so they pay a certain amount for using city right of ways and this sort of thing that contributes to the coffers of their individual communities. The transfer for GRU should be based on a similar formula. It has in the past. It had gone away from that at some point in time, but I think we need to get back to a predictable formula of funds that are... And a fair amount of funds coming from the utility to the city, but that's predictable that you you can base budgeting, long term budgeting on rather than have it changing year to year based on, you know, individual whims.
Nathan Crabbe:So what I'd like to see is is the city and the utility at this point in time need to sit down and have have a serious discussion on on setting that formula and and and going from there so we don't have the sniping back and forth constantly.
Seth:And I think there was that plan in 2023 when all of this was kind of getting started. It landed somewhere between 15 and 20,000,000. Does that sound right to you? You know, I I I couldn't sit sitting here right now. I'd have to look
Nathan Crabbe:at the figures. But, you know, again, I don't... I I think that, I'm interested in what's fair, for for, you know, utility customers too. I don't think that it should be an exorbitant amount of money coming from the utility to the city that would raise people's rates. But we can look...
Nathan Crabbe:I mean, that's the beautiful thing is we can look at other communities and what they're doing, find out what the national standards for these sorts of things and and adopt those. I'm not saying that we need to do anything that's dramatically different from any other community. I think it just needs to be a fair amount that, that goes from the utility of the city so that we can we can have a thriving community. GRU benefits from having a thriving community too, benefits from having a city that's thriving. It's just been a lot of ugly politics in in recent years, and I'd like, hopefully to turn a corner and put some of that in the past and get down to just getting things functioning somewhat normally.
Nathan Crabbe:They might not ever be normally because the GRU authority isn't exactly normal. It's kind of, different from any other utility run-in the country. But if we can get things a little bit closer to normal, that'd be nice.
Seth:Looking forward to January with yours wearing in, what do you anticipate those first few meetings, first few months will look like?
Nathan Crabbe:Well, city manager decision is gonna be the first thing that that happens. We have current interim city manager that I think is doing a very good job, but they've decided to do a a national search, which I think is a good thing. I think you should, if... Even if we're... The the commission decides to choose the, the interim to be the permanent city manager, I think it's always good to do a search to make sure, that that you're you're, being completely informed in that decision.
Nathan Crabbe:So that's that's one of, if not the biggest decision the city commission makes. So that... That'll come pretty pretty soon pretty soon into my tenure. And, you know, you mentioned the Hogtock Green... Creek Greenway.
Nathan Crabbe:I mean, I'd like to get stuff like that going very soon into my tenure. I'd like to see, you know, things land conserved in in in in sensitive areas now rather than waiting because I think that every every minute you wait on stuff like that, the the chances are the land prices go up. There's more chances of development that cause our our our, you know, things like flooding in our community to have to deal with in later years. So let's make the investment now in protecting natural areas would be something that I'd like to get going on pretty soon into my tenure.
Seth:Can't let you talk about protecting natural areas without, you know, the Koppers site is now moving forward. Obviously, long history there, but it does get... You know, this remediation gets underway. They get to a point. Is that something the city should be looking at?
Seth:Is that something the city can look at to have a future with?
Nathan Crabbe:Yeah. I think the city should be planning for the future of the Koppers site. It's 90 acres in the middle of... In the heart of our city. And, you know, the the idea that it's just going to be an empty space forever, I think, was a disservice to to those neighborhoods and their entire community as a whole.
Nathan Crabbe:I think, again, I think that we we need to do sometimes is look around and and what other communities are doing. And I think that you'll see that a lot of people who who have been here a long time saying, oh, this Koppers site's always gonna be, you know, this polluted site. But look at Depot Park. Right? Depot Park was a polluted site too that we've turned into a huge community asset, maybe the jewel of our community.
Nathan Crabbe:And in other communities with similar wood treating sites, they've redeveloped those sites into ball fields, into, you know, things that... Or places where businesses can locate and in in this sort of thing. So I think that when we look towards what we should be doing as a city commission is now that the the cleanup is actually, you know, in in its final stages, hopefully, we should look on to what's next in that site and do something that makes that area an asset to the community and an asset to that neighborhood in particular.
Seth:Sounds good. Nathan Crabbe for City Commission District two. Gonna be joining in January. Thank you for joining us and talking today.
Nathan Crabbe:Thank you for having me. I'll... Anytime that you wanna talk, I'm glad to do so.
